Download PDF


Daval Consulting provides services to colleges, universities, and nonprofit organizations focusing on strengthening their financial and business operations in support of institutional mission.  From serving as an interim CFO to diagnosing and remediating a particular operational issue, Daval tailors the scope of its services to each client’s unique needs.

The firm’s main services include interim executive leadership as a CEO, Executive Director, CFO, or Vice President for Finance and Administration; business diagnostics and re-engineering; and high impact, high profile project management.

John Vitali, Principal at Daval Consulting, is a seasoned and accomplished financial and operational leader in the nonprofit and higher education sectors, with the last twenty-one years in senior executive positions at large, complex organizations.

John excels at advancing an organization’s mission through collaborative team building and data-driven strategic business modeling, helping to build greater financial sustainability in a high-performance culture.

John successfully collaborates with colleagues at all levels – from trustees and faculty to staff, managers, external partners, and consumers.

One hallmark of his leadership style is a strong commitment to diversity while he cultivates future organizational leaders through mentoring, delegating, and promoting.

His work will advance an organization's mission by partnering to envision, shape, promote, and implement new and better ways of operating.

In addition, during his career John cultivated professional relationships with a wide range of operational, technical, and systems experts. For appropriate projects, he can leverage this expertise on an organization's behalf.

See below for:

  • Professional Affiliations via Daval Consulting, LLC
  • Work Experience
  • Project Portfolio of Successes
  • Thinking and Leadership Profile
  • Education
  • Other Professional Affiliations

(June 2024)


NJ Center for Nonprofits, Associate Member. This membership, advocacy, and educational organization exists to support the many 501(c)(3) organizations throughout NJ.

Support Center for Nonprofit Management, Organizational Navigator. The Support Center’s Organizational Navigator program pairs organizations with an experienced nonprofit leader to support long-term change. Navigators are long-standing nonprofit leaders (average experience of over 30 years) who serve as organizational coaches.

  • April 2023 - May 2024, worked as an organizational coach with Board members and leadership teams of two NJ nonprofits -- one as an educational and social services start-up and the other on a major capital construction and fundraising project for a prominent food bank.

Support Center, Interim Executive Director Program. Accredited by the Center for placement as an interim ED for nonprofit organizations in executive transition. In this role John can work as an experienced partner with the Board of Trustees by offering an independent, fresh, and candid perspective; helping the staff adjust to the transition; providing organizational stability of continuous management; and, if requested, conduct an organizational diagnostics program for the Board.

  • December 2023 - June 2024, interim Executive Director for the Society for Classical Studies at New York University; New York, NY. Provided daily executive leadership for programs and operations while conducting an organizational diagnostics review for the Board. This analysis led to the identification and remediation of several operational issues in the finance, technology, and staffing areas.

Freelancers Union, Member.  Since 1995, Freelancers' Union has been on a mission to advocate for and support independent workers.



Daval Consulting, LLC

Advancing the missions of higher education and nonprofit organizations by partnering to envision, shape, promote, and implement new and better ways of operating.

For more information, please visit


CFO and Executive Vice President for Finance and Administration

Drew University

Drew University, Madison, NJ, Mid-June 2016 to June 2021 

CFO and Executive Vice President for Finance and Administration, July 2018 – June 2021

CFO and Vice President for Finance and Administration, Mid-June 2016 – June 2018

About Drew University 

Established in 1867 by the Methodist Episcopal Church as its first US national seminary, Drew University is a private, not-for-profit Phi Beta Kappa liberal arts university. It includes the College of Liberal Arts, the Drew Theological School, and the Caspersen School of Graduate Studies. This distinctive cluster of schools – a classic liberal arts college, a humanities-centered graduate school, and a theology school with Methodist roots and ecumenical concerns – offers unusual opportunities to pursue knowledge across the conventional boundaries of the academy. The Theological and Caspersen Schools offer MA and PhD degrees and the College confers BA degrees in 50 disciplines.  Drew is located on a 186-acre campus, with 1 million gross square feet across 56 buildings. It has a total enrollment of about 2,000 students and has 135 full-time faculty members, 99% of whom hold the terminal degree in their field. The University is home to the independent Shakespeare Theatre of NJ; the Center on Religion, Culture, and Conflict; the Center for Holocaust/Genocide Study; and the United Methodist Archives and History Center.

Leadership Portfolio

Reporting to the President and then Interim President (from August 2020), responsible for departments of Auxiliary Services, Conferences, and Events; Budgeting; Facilities and Campus Operations/Environmental Health and Safety; Finance/Controller (General Accounting, Bursar, and Purchasing); Human Resources; Information Technology; and Risk Management and Insurance. Oversaw $86 million institutional operating budget, investment management for a $170 million endowment through an outsourced Chief Investment Office (CIO), and a $193 million pension fund. Was the lead staff support for Board committees for Audit, Buildings and Grounds, Finance, and Investments.


Significant contributor to a comprehensive multi-year restructuring of mostly non-instructional operations with the goal of sustainably reducing the University’s budgeted expenses, while significantly investing in new student recruitment and student retention. Examples of actions taken include:

  • Staffing reorganizations and downsizings.
  • Identifying and eliminating expensive and low reward non-instructional programs and operations that are no longer mission critical.
  • Right sizing the capital budget.
  • Restructuring employees’ benefits program.
  • Pursuing the monetization of non-core university-owned real estate.
  • Identifying core operating functions eligible for outsourcing to third-party service providers.
  • Seeking to establish expense-sharing relationships with local institutions.

Introduced the University’s first multi-year cash forecast that was fully reconciled with a multi-year GAAP-compliant operating budget.

Successfully restructured $54 million in bond debt. Resulted in a $17 million cash improvement over 5 years.

A major strategic and tactical contributor to the University’s 2018 tuition price resetting, resulting in a Board-approved gross tuition reduction of about $10,000.

Led a major program of physical plant and technological infrastructure renewal for Drew’s 1+ million gross square foot campus, including a five-year deferred maintenance reduction initiative, upgrades to residence halls and instructional space, infrastructure improvements, and a real estate master plan for the management and monetization of non-core and undeveloped University properties.

Resuscitated a dormant Enterprise Risk Management Program with an updated institutional risk inventory, a significant risk matrix, and associated risk mitigation plans with plan owners. The Program was regularly monitored by a high-level University oversight committee and the Board’s Audit Committee.

With the advice and support of the Board’s Audit Committee retained the University’s first internal audit firm to assist with strengthening internal controls, identifying operational inefficiencies, and supporting the Enterprise Risk Management Program.

Successfully negotiated a banking agreement for the University’s purchasing and travel credit card program.  Significantly reduced the number of card holders while strengthening associated internal controls via online banking technology.

During the COVID-19 crisis, led a team that successfully obtained a $7 million loan from the federal Small Business Administration's Payroll Protection Program. That work included convincing the SBA to forgive the University's repayment of the entire $7 million.


CFO and Vice President for Finance and Administration

University of the Sciences in Philadelphia

About USciences:

(In June 2022 USciences merged with St. Joseph's University. The "University City" campus identified on the SJU web site is the former USciences campus.)

A private, not-for-profit coeducational institution distinguished as North America’s first college of pharmacy founded in 1821. Over fifty academic programs are offered through four colleges: pharmacy; health sciences; arts and sciences; and healthcare business and policy. The University’s then 2,000 undergraduate and graduate students are supported by over 170 full-time faculty on a 36-acre campus with high quality instructional, research, and student life facilities. 

Leadership Portfolio

Reporting to the President (and then interim President), was responsible for departments of Finance, Operating and Capital Budgeting, Human Resources, Facilities, Public Safety, Legal Services and Risk Management, and Auxiliary Services. Oversaw a $100 million operating budget, investment management for a $210 million endowment through an outsourced CIO, and a $110 million pension fund. Staff support to Board committees for Audit, Finance, Facilities, and Investments.  


Conceived, organized, trained, and led two inaugural standing tri-partite University committees that were chiefly faculty-driven. One committee addressed the operating budget and the other dealt with the capital budget and facilities oversight.  These two teams strengthened University governance, financial and physical plant literacy, and institutional transparency.

Led a16-month campus facilities master planning process that gave the University a realistic and affordable 10-year plan to significantly improve student housing via off-balance sheet financing; add new learning, research, and sports facilities; repurpose other buildings to provide more instructional, research, and student activity space while eliminating expensive property leases; use existing instructional space more efficiently; and further beautify the campus and its adjacent neighborhood. Directed by the University Board in May 2015 to begin implementing the master plan in phases with Phase 1 focused on the design and construction of a 416-bed student residence hall.

Supported the interim President as the lead planner and implementer of a board-approved multi-year strategic turnaround plan that included stabilizing the senior management team, expanding the enrollment function, an academic and administrative program review, an institutional re-branding effort, and a major capital fundraising campaign.

Navigated the University through the refinancing of $90 million in bond debt, saving $7.2 million. Successfully sustained the institution’s A- and A3, stable credit ratings with Fitch and Moody’s.

Converted traditional “bricks & mortar” bookstore to an online system. Former bookstore space converted to a high-quality convenience store for the campus and surrounding neighborhood.

Successfully re-negotiated a 10-year $30 million contract with an international dining services provider.  Strengthened terms of the contract to better protect the University’s interests and raised the annual commission rate paid to the institution from 4% to 9%.


CFO and Executive Vice President for Finance and Administration

Brooklyn Public Library

About Brooklyn Public Library

Annually serving over 1 million customers, this premier 100+ year old independent 501(c) 3 urban public library system was the fifth largest in the US and the ninth largest nonprofit cultural organization in NY City. The BPL system includes a Borough-wide campus of 58 neighborhood libraries, a business library, and its flagship Central Library. It had an operating budget of $100 million, a $62+ million capital budget, a staff of 1,400 full- and part-time employees in a unionized environment, and 1,500 volunteers. Among the largest education organizations in Brooklyn, at the time the Library annually delivered high quality adult literacy and life-long learning programs to 40,000 people.

Executive Vice President for Finance and Administration and CFO, 2005 to June 2013

Deputy Director for Finance and Administration, 2002 to 2005

Director of Finance, 2000 to 2002

Reporting to the Executive Director and then the President/CEO, since 2002 had enterprise-wide responsibility for Division of Finance and Administration, including Capital Planning and Facilities Management, Finance, General Counsel, Human Resources, Information Technology, and Public Safety. Led a staff of 250+ through six direct reports.

Executive staff support for four Board committees including preparation of agendas, support for trustee chairs, and preparation and presentation of materials. Committees included Audit, Capital Planning and Facilities, Finance, and Investments. 

Financial Leadership

Fiscal management resulted in thirteen consecutive years of unqualified opinions from independent auditors with only minor management letter issues.

Introduced organization’s first GAAP-compliant monthly and quarterly financial reporting packages and an enterprise-wide rolling budget planning and management model. Led to a more collaborative, accountable, and transparent budget process.

Through strategic cash budgeting and stronger internal controls moved organization in two years from a serious cash deficit to sustained positive cash flow.

Restructured long-term investments, which grew over 10 years from $15 million to $34 million. Represented the trustees’ investment committee in routine interactions with investment advisors.

Established a durable culture of financial transparency and accountability via 100% compliance with select board-approved voluntary Sarbanes-Oxley program.

Operational Leadership

Led cross-functional teams that conceived, promoted and implemented innovative, sustainable enterprise-wide improvements that were game-changing, leading to service and business models that were more entrepreneurial, integrated, reliable, efficient and economical.

Examples --

  • A multi-award-winning reservation and print management system for 1100 public computers and 300 printers using 65 touch-screen self-service transactional kiosks with integrated library and “smart debit card” technology. Repurposed nearly $2 million in supplies and highly trained professional labor to the delivery of core services and programs. Led to a new annual revenue stream of $300,000 and stronger internal controls through cash-less operations at all sites.
  • A distinctive service relationship with United Parcel Service to fully support a 60-site intra-library delivery service. Cut the book-to-customer delivery cycle from seven business days to 24 hours, while annually moving over five million books and other library materials. Introduced real-time tracking technology for all deliveries. Eliminated escalating in-house fleet costs, substantively reduced financial risk, and afforded significant release time for professional staff to grow core programs and services.
  • Led a cross-functional team of City officials, Library staff, and outside consultants to implement a self-funding strategic real estate master plan for BPL’s 58 neighborhood libraries. Plan endorsed by NY City as an innovative, cost-effective approach to mixed-use developments for new libraries with luxury and market-rate housing.  Library announced its first successful developer partnership leading to a new condo high rise with a new replacement library at street-level and a $40 million unrestricted allocation to the Library’s capital renewal budget.
  • Introduced a passport service sanctioned by the US State Department that within two years was then annually grossing $500,000 and a net profit of $375,000. Due to the inaugural site's success, a second site was opened in another section of Brooklyn.

Multiple Management and Executive Leadership Roles

Higher Education and Nonprofit Organizations

During this period John held several increasingly responsible finance and administration leadership positions, including at the Vice Presidential/CFO level, at nonprofit organizations and at colleges and universities in the NY Metro Area.


Shown here are representative examples of John's work.

Strategic and Tactical Financial and Operational Leadership

During his extended career as a nonprofit and higher education business leader and partner, John Vitali routinely oversaw multi-million-dollar institutional operating and capital budgets; finance operations, including General Accounting, Bursar, and Purchasing; and the investment management of large endowments and pension funds through outsourced Chief Investment Officers and other third-party experts.

Campus Real Estate and Capital Infrastructure Improvements at Drew University

A broad portfolio of real estate and capital infrastructure improvement projects ranging from the monetization of assorted non-core housing properties and a thoughtful, yet purposeful discussion about property development through a public-private partnership to the installation of new instructional spaces and plant infrastructure improvements.

Campus Master Plan at University of the Sciences

From January 2014 through May 2015 John led the campus master plan development process at University of the Sciences.  At the University's May 2015 board meeting the trustees approved a phased implementation of the updated plan starting with a student residence hall for 400+ students.  That res hall is now fully in use.

Here are two slide presentations. The first, on the left, shows the planning process and its results.  The second, on the right, shows final design, programming, and facility locations after new property was acquired. Please click on each photo and allow time for the file to open.

XEROX Technology Project at Brooklyn Public Library

A multi-award-winning reservation and print management system for now 1100 public PCs and 300 printers using 65 touch-screen self-service transactional kiosks with integrated library and “smart debit card” technology. Repurposed nearly $2 million in supplies and highly trained professional labor to the delivery of core services and programs. Led to improved customer service, a new annual revenue stream of $370,000 and stronger internal controls through cash-less operations at all sites.

UPS "Supply Chain" Project at Brooklyn Public Library

A distinctive service relationship with United Parcel Service to fully support a 60-site intra-library delivery service. Cut the book-to-customer delivery cycle from seven business days to 24 hours, while annually moving over five million books and other library materials. Introduced real-time tracking technology for all deliveries. Eliminated escalating in-house fleet costs, substantively reduced financial risk, and afforded significant release time for professional staff to grow core programs and services.

Capital Projects at Brooklyn Public Library

While at BPL, John Vitali was responsible for supervising several multi-million-dollar capital construction and renovation projects. Samples of those projects are illustrated here.


An independent Korn-Ferry assessment of John Vitali's thinking and leadership styles, showing how John behaves most naturally without giving much thought to the image he is projecting to other people and how he makes decisions when interacting with other people. John acknowledges that this report is dated; however, he believes it remains an insightful picture of the thinking and leadership styles he has demonstrated throughout his career.



M. Ed.

Rutgers University

Higher Education Administration



Saint Peter's College (now University)

History with a concentration in Russian Area Studies


Financial Executives Networking Group, Member since 1999.  Founded in 1991 The FENG is an internationally recognized organization for senior financial professionals with over 50,000 worldwide members. Membership is by invitation.

Endowment Trustee, American Library Association, 2007 -- 2012.  This 5-member group is appointed by the Association’s national Executive Board. It serves as the ALA’s investment committee for its then nearly $35 million long-term investment portfolio. Appointed Senior Trustee (Chair) by the ALA Board in June 2012.

Edison Township Free Public Library System’s Board of Trustees, Member 2008 -- 2013. Nominated by the Mayor and confirmed by the Township Council, this board has full fiduciary responsibility for the library system's operations, programs and services.